Automatic Bollards vs Electric Gates: Which Should You Choose?

Electric gates are often the go-to solution for securing a property. That said, automatic bollards are becoming more popular across Yorkshire, especially where gates are not practical.

In some cases, bollards can be the better option. This guide explains the key differences and helps you decide what suits your property best.

Space and Entrance Layout

The layout of your entrance plays a big role.

Electric gates need space:

• Swing gates require room to open
• Sliding gates need space to run back

If your entrance is tight or opens directly onto a road, gates may not work well.

For example, a narrow driveway in York with walls either side may not allow space for gates. Bollards solve this by rising from the ground when needed and disappearing when not in use.

They also work well for wide entrances or multi-lane access, such as commercial sites in Leeds or Bradford.

Appearance and Surroundings

In areas like York or Harrogate, appearance can matter just as much as security.

Gates can change how a property looks, which may not suit conservation areas or certain buildings.

Bollards are more discreet:

• Flush with the ground when lowered
• Minimal visual impact
• Maintain open views

For example, a hotel or property in a historic setting may prefer bollards to keep the entrance open while still controlling access.

Traffic Flow and Flexibility

Bollards are ideal where traffic needs to be managed throughout the day.

They allow:

• Open access during busy periods
• Restricted access when needed
• Timed or scheduled control

This is common for:

• City centre access points
• Car parks
• Schools and commercial sites

A site in Leeds may keep bollards down during the day, then raise them after hours to secure the entrance.

Gates can do this too, but bollards allow a fully open entrance when not in use.

Security Differences

Gates and bollards provide security in different ways.

Electric gates:

• Create a full barrier
• Control both vehicles and pedestrians
• Offer privacy

Bollards:

• Stop vehicles
• Prevent unauthorised access
• Offer strong protection against vehicle entry

If your main concern is stopping vehicles, bollards are highly effective. If you want full enclosure and privacy, gates are usually the better choice.

Access Control Options

Both systems can be paired with access control.

Common options include:

• Remote fobs
• Keypads
• Intercom systems

Bollards are useful where multiple users need access, such as apartment blocks or shared spaces.

Gates are often better for private homes with a single entrance.

Installation and Maintenance

Bollards require:

• Ground excavation
• Drainage
• Power connections

Gates require:

• Posts or pillars
• Space for movement
• Electrical setup

Both need maintenance to stay reliable.

Bollards need regular checks for drainage and sealing, especially in Yorkshire weather. Gates require motor, hinge and safety system checks.

Cost Overview

Bollards are often more expensive than a basic gate, especially if multiple units are installed.

Costs depend on:

• Number of units
• Groundworks
• Access control setup

That said, if bollards solve a layout or access issue, they can be the better long-term option.

When to Choose Each Option

Choose electric gates if:

• You want full boundary security
• Privacy is important
• The layout allows space

Choose bollards if:

• Space is limited
• You want a discreet solution
• Vehicle control is the priority

In some cases, combining both may work best.

---

If you are unsure whether electric gates or bollards are right for your property, Rawson Automation can help.

The team works across Leeds, Huddersfield, Bradford, Wakefield, York and Harrogate, designing systems to suit each site.

---

Quick FAQ

Are bollards better than gates?

It depends on the site. Bollards are best for vehicle control, gates are better for full access control.

Do bollards stop pedestrians?

No, they are mainly for vehicle access.

Are bollards suitable for homes?

Yes, especially where space is limited.

Are bollards more expensive?

Often, yes, due to groundwork and installation.

Can both be used together?

Yes, combining systems can improve security and flexibility.